![The Misguidance of Ustadh Abd al-Rahman Hassan
Here is our “Ustādh” again…with a false understanding:
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said, “….and he made him bleed until he wounded his head and the blood was coming out of his face, because he was an innovator. I say to those people today: Why don’t you take this athar and every innovator – why don’t you beat them up?”
Because ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb was the LEADER of the Muslims. It is not upon the layman to take matters into his own hands. When ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb expelled him to Īrāq, did the laymen of ʿĪrāq beat him? No, rather they BOYCOTTED him until ʿUmar allowed them to speak to him! [Al-Ājurrī – al-Sharīʿah, p.74]
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said: “The reason is because it is not the right time, right? Exactly! Boycotting is the same!..”
Questioner:
When is it allowed to cut off and boycott an innovator? And is it allowed to boycott an innovation in this time?
Shaykh Zayd al-Madkhalī:
The ruling in relation to boycotting an innovator is NOT restricted to a time or place, however, before boycotting, it is clarified to the innovator. It is clarified to him; he is shown his mistake, and the correct way is shown to him. This is [done] before he is boycotted. Thereafter, we see if he has benefitted from the clarification and advice, [if he has benefitted and abandoned the innovation], then he is not boycotted. But if he insists upon his innovation, and spreads it among the people, then he is boycotted and warned against continuously, [there is no specific amount of time]. And when he returns to the truth and accepts it, the boycotting is then stopped. Just as the way of the people of knowledge, those who spread and defend the Sunnah, those who clarify the mistakes of innovations and the innovators, and those who warn against innovations and its people. The books of knowledge are filled with this.
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said: “And I give you the same example: ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib, a man asked him about the same thing, the same shubuha, he brought āyāt mutashābihāt. ʿAlī was sitting one day and he said to the people: “…Who wants to ask me a question, who has a question?” ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib, raḍi Allāhu ʿanhu, – a man stood up and said: “I have a question, and he asked the question. ʿĀlī was shocked about the question which he asked because it was from the āyāt that were mutashābihāt. Ālī did not stand up, get a stick and beat him up, cause Ālī’s time, was not the time for what? What did Ālī do? He said: “May Allāh kill you!” That’s all he could do, that’s his power now. He could just curse him..!?”
Ibn Taymīyyah said: The first innovation to appear in Islām was the bidʿah of the Khawārij and the Shīʿah. It appeared during the rule of ʿĀlī ibn Abī Ṭālib, and he PUNISHED these two groups. As for the Khawārij, they fought him so he KILLED them. As for the Shīʿah, then he BURNT the extremist from amongst them with fire after killing them…” [al-Majmūʿ, vol. 3, p464].
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said: “May Allāh’s curse be upon him. May Allāh’s curse be upon him. This is what we’re saying. The Saḥābah were looking at the time and the place…”
The COMPANION, Jundub al-Azdī, said: “We MARCHED with Ālī ibn Abī Ṭālib against the Khawārij and reached their camps.” [Tarīkh al-Umām wal-Mulūk, v.6, p.42]
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said: “At the time of Ālī, his leadership was doubtful. He was not in a position where his imārah, his leadership – was fully agreed upon. There was khilāf. ʿUmar’s time was what? Ijmāʿ, consensus. So if Ālī spoke, his leadership, everything….so he couldn’t speak…he couldn’t deal with it like that..”
The great companion, the rightly guided Khalāfah, ʿĀlī ibn Abī Ṭālib: “couldn’t deal with it like that…”!!!?
Yāqūt said: “ʿĀlī ibn Abī Ṭālib FOUGHT the Khawārij at al-Nahra’wān.” [Muʿjam al-Buldān 95/3750]
Ibn al-Jawzī said: “Nearly 2000 from the Khawārij retracted and joined Ālī’s forces while the rest [of the Khawārij] revolted against him and they were KILLED.” [Talbīs Iblīs, p.31]
ʿAbd al-Raḥmān Ḥasan said, “We say the same thing brothers, when the boycott is a hāl, it is a situation, it can be dealt with, it can …. the religion, please, we’re the first to deal with you guys wallāh. But when it is not going to work, and boycotting the people is not going to work, then we’re going to go to the houses, we’re going to call them, we’re going to bring them to our gatherings, we’re going to give them daʿwah for them to leave what they are upon. Why? مراعاة المصالح والمفاسد To look at the maṣālih and the mafāsid…”
https://dusunnah.com/video/the-misguidance-of-ustadh-abdulrahman-hassan/
#amau #arh #abdurrahmanhassan #abdurrahmanhasan](https://abuhamzah.net/wp-content/plugins/youtube-feed-pro/img/placeholder.png)
The Tamyee' of "Ustadh" Abdur Rahman Hasan
Khariji Doubt: "Why should we obey ruler? We haven't given Baya'ah to him!" (Feat: FazlurRahman)
Jamiat India "Ameer" Asghar Ali Mahdi invites honors misguiding Murji Innovator AbulFitan al-Maribee
Jamiati Rahmani insults Ahlul Hadeeth scholars to justify the Shirk of deviant Jamaat Ghuraba
Junagarhi & Ahlul Hadeeth scholars of India reject Shirk of Jamaat Ghuraba & founder Abdul Wahhab
Hizbee India Jamiat Oath to pledge allegiance to Constitution & Baatil Ameer (Asghar Ali & Kindi)
Shaikh SafiurRahman Mubarakpuri warns against Sufi Deobandi Makki al-Hijaazi (Mudarris Haram Makkah)
Jamiatis & Baatil Ikhwani principle "Take the Good from Everyone" misintepret Hadith Abu Hurayrah
R.K. Noor Madani Jamiati (employee of Zakir Naik's Peace TV Urdu) meets the Innovator Ali al-Halabi
Who defends innovators al-Maghrâwî, Saleem al-Hilâlî, Ali al-Halabî, al-Marîbî | Sh. an-Najmî
Demonstrations only became known through the West | Shaykh al Fawzan
Demonstrations are always chaotic and harmful to a Society | Shaykh al Fawzan ﷾
About establishing Islâmic parties - Shaikh al-Albânî
Ahmadullah of Peace TV Bangla praises the Mubtadi al-Qaradhawi & recommends his Misguiding books
Undercover Ikhwanis of Bangladeshi Jamiat lavishly praising Innovator Maududi & slandering Scholars
Shaykh Ubayd al-Jabiree (رحمه الله) about Qutbiyyah (sect of Ikhwaanul-Mujrimeen)
Shaykh Ubayd al-Jabiree (رحمه الله) about the Qutubi Surooree al-Munajjid (IslamQA)
Undercover Ikhwanis of Bangladeshi Jamiat praising Innovators like al-Qaradawi & slandering Scholars
Flip-Flop Nasir al-Hanbali & support to Rafidhah supporting Innovator Muhammad (al-Imam) ar-Reemi
Undercover Ikhwani Indian Jamiat praising Mubtadi al-Qaradawi at Conference to promote misguidance
What if the ruler allows demonstrations? - Imâm Muhammad bin Sâlih bin 'Uthaymin (رحمه الله)
Innovators & Hizbees of Misguiding Jamiat Dar al-Ber: Naik, Abu Zaid Zameer, ARH, Tim, Motiur Rahman
Obeying Rulers Who Do Not Rule By Shariah - Shaykh Ibn Bâz (رحمه الله)
Condemning the rulers from the pulpits - Shaykh Ibn Bâz (رحمه الله)
Deviant Abdur Rahman Hassan goes India to meet Turathi Hizbees of Jamiat, who slander the Scholars
Jamiati Abu Zaid Zameer recommends the website of Qutubi Surooree Mubtadi al-Munajjid (IslamQA)
Shaikh Rabee al-Madkhali & other scholars warning against Haddadi Falih al-Harbee & his Fajir Sect
Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai publicly cursing Rulers from Minbar, calling them Traitors & compare to Taghoot
Nasir al-Hanbali, Khalid Uthman al-Misri & their Hizbee Protestor Scholars from Jamiat of Pakistan
STOP KISSING DEVIANTS (Ft: Uthman Farooq, Zakir Naik, Said Kamali + Abu Taqiyyah)
Hafiz Zubair Ali Zai teaching Deviant Engineer Mirza Jhelumi to preach against Aqeedah AhlusSunnah
Ikhwani Dawah of Mohamed Hoblos, Promoting Mawlid Bidah & Sufis, Shirk Singers, Movies etc.
Uthman al-Khamees (kissed by Uthman Farooq) kissed the Takfiri Innovator Abu Ishaq al-Huwayni
Sh. Muqbil warned against innovators: Abdur-Rahman Abdul-Khaliq, Huwainī, Audah, Hawali, Suroor
"Abu Isḥaq al-Huwainī is from the Khawārij" | Shaykh Muḥammad al-Bannā
Uthman Farooq reveals his Hizbee links with Ihya Turath al-Bidaati #uthmankhamis #uthmanfarooq
Refutation of Uthmaan al-Khamees by Shaykh Abdullaah Dhafiri ﷾
Cheating on exams - Shaikh ibn Baz
Are witnesses need to take the Shahada? - Shaykh Fawzan
Doubt from Grave Worshippers (Do awliyaa' have ability to answer one's prayers?) - Shaykh Fawzan
Failed attempt to convert Arabia to Christianity - Shaykh Abdullah bin Muhammad bin Humaid
History and Origin of the term Wahhabi Explained by Shaykh al Albani
The Tears of Ibn Bāz
Are the followers of an innovator abandoned as he is abandoned? - Shaikh Rabīʿ Al-Madkhalī
Dr Murtaza Bakhsh recommends his Hizbee Allies: Jamiati Syed Meraj Rabbani
Shaikh Wasiullah Abbas & Shaikh Abu Khadeejah speak about Ismail Menk & Jamiati Hizbee collaborators
تحذير الشيخ العلامة المحدث ربيع المدخلي حفظه الله من جمعية دار البر الإماراتية
Murtaza Bakhsh rebuking Muslim Rulers, warned against by Ustadh Kashiff Khan ﷾ & Tariq Ali Brohi ﷾
Early Jamiati Response against Ignorance & Misguidance of Deviant Zakir Naik - Abdul Hamid Rahmani
Dr Zakir Naik Claims You Can Go to al-Jannah without Believing in the Prophet! ﷺ
Zakir Naik Does Not Understand the Message of Islam!
Ahmed Deedat Exposed (He Says Mawlid And Christmas Can Be Celebrated)
'Maro Sale Ko' technique of debate: Ahmed Deedat teaching Dr Zakir Naik (2)
Ahmed Deedat (rahimahullah) - Inappropriate hand gestures and belittling fiqh discussions
Ahmed Deedat's flattery of Khomeini (May Allah's Laanah be upon Khomeini)
Review of Shadeed Muhammad's "The Mardiyah Show"
The "Kamal El Mekki Magic" Scandal at Green Lane Masjid (Part 1)
Who is Shadeed Muhammad? (Let His Twitter Speak For Him!)
Response to "Dawah to Eminem" by Imran ibn Mansur
More of Shadeed Muhammad's Misbehaviour on Social Media
Post-Yale Yasir Qadhi Accepted by Shia Imams at Ikhwani ISNA Convention
Umar Lee, Author of "The Rise and Fall of the Salafi Dawah"
Who is Shadeed Muhammad? (Let His Twitter Speak #2)
From Minister Louis Farrakhan's Teachings: "The People of the Cave"
Ghulu 101: Siraj Wahhaj is a 'LIVING LEGEND'
Khalid Yasin Adopts the Jahmite Teachings of Yusuf Estes
The Jahmi Statements Yusuf Estes Claims He Never Said!
How to Send Someone a Private Message on YouTube (2014)
The "Yasir Qadhi - Tony Blair" Relationship Examined (Part 1)
Yasir Qadhi and Sufi-Ashari Suhaib Webb: Ikhwani Bonding
Another Review of Shadeed Muhammad's 'The Mardiyah Show'
Jahmi-Leaks #1: Yusuf Estes on TROID, Bilal Philips, Moosa Richardson
The "Yasir Qadhi - Tony Blair" Relationship Examined (Part 2)
Hamza Tzortzis & "Dawah Man" Imran ibn Mansur Show Us How NOT to Give Dawah
Yusuf Estes: Saudi Arabia is not an Islamic State, Nobody Ever Said it Was
Post-Yale Yasir Qadhi: A Changed Man, a Changed Aqidah
Almaghrib Institute Uses the Kabah to Market their Expensive Seminars
Sh. Fawzan on Studying Islam from Non Muslims
Does Real Islam Include Sufism and Shiism?
Haitham Haddad on Bad Muslims Who Can't Read Quran Properly
Hamza Tzortzis About Hizbut Tahrir (HT)
The Hero of Western Social Media Stars: Muhammad Al Arifi
Tahir Wyatt, Promotional Tool for Louis Farrakhan's Nation of Islam
Shaikh Al-Albani: The Islaimc Ruling on Freemasons
Be Warned of Said Rageah the Liar! (Imam @ Sakinah Community Center)
Almaghrib Institute Official Promotional Cartoons Featuring Yasir Qadhi
Shaikh Fawzan on Someone who Claims He Knows 1000 Things Allah Cannot Do! "He is a mulhid!"
Yusuf Estes "R-RATED" Fashion Show for Muslim Ladies
Yasir Qadhi's Scholars at Yale University (Part 2)
Abdur Raheem McCarthy's Ghulu (Extremism) and Slander
Yasir Qadhi Depicts the Scholars as a Bunch of Clowns
Is Yusuf Estes Shia or Sunni? 8 Reasons for Concern
News Report: Yusuf Estes has Fallen From a TV Tower
Imran Hosein on Saudi Arabia: "Goodbye to Bad Rubbish"
Whose Life is Yasir Qadhi Referring to as a "Fairy Tale"?
Deviants "Decode" the Torah to Reveal Harun Yahya is the Mahdi?!
QUESTION: Is that a Shia Book in My Video?
SIraj Wahhaj Sold Out to Farrakhan and the 'Nation of Islam'
Omar Sulaiman and Sufi Ashari Suhaib Webb: Engage the Political Process!
Yasir Qadhi Separates You from the Muslim Scholars
